Law Experts Discuss the Future of Justice in the Age of Artificial Intelligence
Kareem Mohamed Khater
Artificial intelligence is no longer merely a peripheral technology making its way into lawyers’ offices and investigation rooms. It has become an active participant in the justice system, capable of sorting evidence, analysing recordings, suggesting legal arguments, and assisting in legal research and case-law analysis.
While these tools promise to accelerate legal proceedings and enhance efficiency, they also raise questions that are no less serious than the technology itself: Who bears responsibility when an AI system makes a mistake? How can defendants be guaranteed a fair trial when facing an algorithmic opponent whose reasoning they may not understand? And are we witnessing the emergence of a partner to the judge, or a potential replacement?

These and other questions formed the focus of a discussion with a distinguished group of specialists in criminal law, digital transformation, litigation, and arbitration, examining the future of justice in the age of artificial intelligence.
Addressing the ethical and legal safeguards governing the use of AI, Judge Dr Mohamed Talaat Saeed, Senior Appeal Judge at the Egyptian Economic Courts, seconded faculty member at the Arab Academy for Science, Technology and Maritime Transport, and accredited arbitrator at Egypt’s Ministry of Justice, outlines the key principles that should govern the deployment of artificial intelligence in the judicial field.
These include transparency and explainability, fairness and non-discrimination, privacy protection, accountability, and ensuring meaningful human oversight of the outputs generated by intelligent systems.
He stresses that artificial intelligence must remain an assistive tool for judges and cannot replace their human experience or their ability to assess the facts and circumstances surrounding each individual case.
On the impact of these technologies on judicial independence and impartiality, Judge Dr Mohamed Talaat Saeed warns of the risks of algorithmic bias, particularly when intelligent systems rely on unbalanced datasets, potentially leading to unjust outcomes.
He points out that the risk of bias is not confined to the data used to train these systems; it also extends to the stages of information analysis, interpretation, and the presentation of results. Accordingly, he argues that AI-generated outputs should be treated as supporting indicators subject to scrutiny and review, rather than as definitive facts.
Turning to Egypt’s position in this transformation, Judge Dr Mohamed Talaat Saeed explains that Cairo has taken significant steps through the National Council for Artificial Intelligence and the National Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2025–2030, alongside ongoing efforts to digitise courts and the Public Prosecution.
He notes that existing legislation, including Electronic Signature Law No. 15 of 2004, the Anti-Cybercrime Law No. 175 of 2018, and the Personal Data Protection Law No. 151 of 2020, provides an important legal framework. However, these laws do not eliminate the need for comprehensive legislation specifically regulating the use of artificial intelligence and establishing clear lines of liability for errors arising from intelligent systems.
From the Egyptian experience to the Emirati model, the discussion turns to lawyer Nervine Magdy Hassan Fayed, an appellate lawyer based in the United Arab Emirates and a researcher pursuing a Master’s degree in Legal Artificial Intelligence.
She explains that the UAE is moving towards developing a judicial model that harnesses artificial intelligence applications while preserving judicial independence. This approach is grounded in Article 94 of the UAE Constitution, which guarantees the independence of the judiciary, Federal Decree-Law No. 45 of 2021 on Personal Data Protection, as well as other legislation governing judicial practice.








Yorum Yazın